TYPO3 vs Drupal: A CMS comparison

Welcome to the world of content management systems like TYPO3 and Drupal - two CMS giants that manage millions of websites in the background. It feels like choosing between tea and coffee. Both are great, have their fans and keep your website running - but each has its own flavor.

In one corner we have TYPO3: strong in Europe, super secure and built for big projects. On the other is Drupal: flexible, popular worldwide and powers over a million websites (yes, that many!).

But which one should you choose? That's exactly what we want to find out. We'll compare features, real-life use cases, pros and cons and all the important factors.

Ready for a stress-free comparison? Let's go!

An open source content management system (CMS) is software that enables users to create, manage and edit digital content on a website - without the need for technical knowledge. It offers a user-friendly interface for editing texts, images and videos and supports content management. Well-known CMS platforms are TYPO3, WordPress and Drupal. These systems simplify the maintenance of websites, especially for non-technical users, by separating content from design and layout.

TYPO3 has been an open source CMS since 1998 and is particularly popular in German-speaking countries. It is built for large, complex web projects and offers multi-site management and support for multiple languages. With around 1,600 extensions , it can be individually adapted to business requirements. Anyone looking for a CMS content management system for an enterprise project will find the necessary scalability and flexibility in TYPO3.

Find out more in our current TYPO3 blog .

Drupal is a flexible, open-source CMS known for its scalability and customizability. It was released in 2001 and is popular for complex websites such as blogs, e-commerce platforms and community websites. With over 40,000 modules to extend functionality, it is used by large organizations and governments worldwide. Drupal's strength lies in its active community, security features and its ability to manage dynamic content on a large scale.

1. User Interface & User-Friendliness

• TYPO3: Intuitive interface for editors. Learning curve through TypoScript. Drag-and-drop functionality allows users to create and manage content efficiently, promoting intuitive operation and minimizing training requirements.
• Drupal: Modern, accessible admin interface. Customizable, even for non-technical users. Drag-and-drop functionality greatly improves the usability and flexibility of the CMS.

2. Multilingualism & Multi-site Capability

• TYPO3: Native multilingualism, backend in user language possible, centralized management of multiple websites.
• Drupal: Over 100 languages, multi-site possible - but requires more configuration.

3. Extensions & Customization

• TYPO3: 1,600 extensions in the TYPO3 extension repository, easy integration.
• Drupal: Over 40,000 modules, high flexibility, but technical know-how required.

4. Performance & Scalability

• TYPO3: High performance for complex pages, effective caching, PHP 8.0 compatible.
• Drupal: Large content volume and traffic, scalable architecture.

5. Security & Maintenance

• TYPO3: Regular updates with LTS and ELTS, security and compliance standards.
• Drupal: Strong security record, dedicated security team, regular patches.

6. SEO & Marketing Tools

• TYPO3: Integrated SEO system, optimizable URLs & metadata.
• Drupal: Extensive SEO modules, flexible taxonomy system.

7 AI Integration

• TYPO3: T3AI extension for content suggestions, analysis, personalization.
• Drupal: AI functions via third-party modules - more setup required.

8. Accessibility

• TYPO3: Focus on accessibility, EAA-compliant, extensions for support.
• Drupal: Extensive accessibility features, many modules to improve usability.

Note:"This information is based on publicly available sources and official documentation at the time of writing. Features, usage figures and market share are subject to change. Please visit the official TYPO3 and Drupal websites for up-to-date data."

Both platforms are flexible when it comes to connecting external tools. Can be integrated with, among others:

• E-commerce: Magento, Shopify
• CRM: Salesforce, HubSpot
• Marketing: Mailchimp, Matomo

TYPO3: Well-structured APIs, ideal for individual integrations with reliable performance.

Drupal: "API-first" approach, particularly suitable for headless setups and omnichannel content. Drupal is an excellent example of a headless CMS (content management system) that impresses with its flexibility and customizability.

The installation and commissioning of a content management system can shape the first impression and lay the foundation for future use.

TYPO3 offers a detailed installation guide that is suitable for both beginners and experienced developers. However, the installation requires some technical knowledge, especially when configuring the server and the database. TYPO3 uses Composer for package management, which facilitates the installation of extensions and updates. Once installed, TYPO3 offers a comprehensive backend interface that can seem a little overwhelming at first, but is very powerful after a short training period.

Drupal, on the other hand, is known for its flexibility and customizability right from the installation stage. The installation of Drupal is relatively simple and can be carried out via a web-based user interface. Again, Composer is used to manage modules and dependencies. Drupal offers a variety of installation profiles that make it possible to adapt the basic configuration to the specific needs of the project. This can be particularly beneficial for complex projects, but also requires a certain amount of technical know-how.

Overall, the installation of both systems is well documented, but TYPO3 can have a steeper learning curve due to its complexity. Drupal scores with its flexibility and customizable installation profiles, which makes it attractive for a wide range of projects.

Maintenance and regular updates are crucial for the security and performance of a CMS (content management system).

TYPO3 offers a structured update process with Long-Term Support (LTS) and Extended Long-Term Support (ELTS). LTS versions are supported for three years, while ELTS versions receive additional security updates for up to four years. This gives companies the security of knowing that their websites will be supported in the long term. TYPO3 updates are well documented, but often require technical expertise, especially for major version jumps.

Drupal relies on regular core updates and security patches that are monitored by a dedicated security team. The update frequency is higher than with TYPO3, which means that administrators have to install updates more frequently. On the one hand, this can increase security, but on the other hand it can also increase maintenance costs. Drupal also offers detailed instructions and tools for automating updates, which makes the process easier.

Both systems place great emphasis on security and stability, but TYPO3 offers longer support with its LTS and ELTS versions, while Drupal ensures continuous improvement and security through more frequent updates.

The user-friendliness and efficiency of the editorial interface are crucial for day-to-day work with a CMS (content management system).

TYPO3 offers an intuitive user interface that has been specially developed for editors. The backend is clearly laid out and makes it easy to manage content. The learning curve can be steep at first, especially due to TypoScript, a custom scripting language for configuration. However, once editors are familiar with the interface, they can work efficiently and productively. TYPO3 also offers extensive rights management options, which is particularly advantageous in large organizations.

Drupal scores with a modern and accessible admin interface that can be easily adapted to the needs of users. User-friendliness is further enhanced by a wide range of modules and themes that make editorial work easier. Drupal also offers a flexible roles and permissions system that allows fine-grained control over access rights. The learning curve is flatter than with TYPO3, which makes it more attractive for beginners.

Both systems offer powerful editing interfaces, but TYPO3 requires more initial training, while Drupal stands out for its customizability and ease of use.

Search engine optimization (SEO) is an essential factor for the success of a website.

TYPO3 offers integrated SEO tools that make it possible to optimize URLs, metadata and other SEO-relevant settings directly in the backend. Extensions such as Yoast SEO for TYPO3 offer additional features to improve TYPO3 SEO performance. TYPO3 makes it possible to efficiently implement SEO strategies and increase visibility in search engines.

Drupal has a variety of SEO modules that enable comprehensive optimization. Modules such as Pathauto, Metatag and XML Sitemap are just a few examples that extend Drupal's SEO capabilities. Drupal's flexible taxonomy system enables precise categorization and tagging of content, which further improves SEO performance. The customizability of the SEO modules makes Drupal a powerful platform for search engine optimization.

Both systems offer strong SEO features, but Drupal scores with its modularity and flexibility, while TYPO3 impresses with its integrated tools and extensions.

Community support and available resources are crucial for the long-term success of a CMS (content management system).

TYPO3 has an active and dedicated community, especially in German-speaking countries. There are numerous forums, mailing lists and events that promote exchange and support. The TYPO3 Association also offers official training courses and certifications to ensure the quality and professionalism of TYPO3 developers.

Drupal has one of the largest and most active open source communities in the world. The Drupal community is known for its helpfulness and the wealth of resources available, including forums, documentation, training and events such as DrupalCon. The strong international presence of the community ensures that users can always find support.

Both systems benefit from strong communities, but Drupal has a slight advantage due to its global reach and wealth of resources. TYPO3, on the other hand, offers a close-knit and supportive community, especially in the DACH region.

These new sections provide a comprehensive comparison of the two CMS (content management systems) and help readers make an informed decision.

Market share & popularity

TYPO3:

• Market share Germany: 14.2
• 2nd place after WordPress
• Worldwide: 500,000+ installations, strong in DACH
• Particularly suitable for large corporate websites due to its stability and flexibility

Drupal:

• Worldwide: ~1.2 % of all websites
• Sectors: Governments, educational institutions (e.g. NASA, EU Commission)
• Ideal for corporate websites with complex requirements

Extension ecosystem

TYPO3:

• 1,600 extensions, curated for enterprise applications

Drupal:

• 40,000+ modules - e-commerce, content, SEO, APIs

Security & stability

TYPO3:

• 3 years LTS, 4 years ELTS

Drupal:

• Deployed at NASA, EU - strong security team, detailed reports

Performance & scalability

TYPO3:

• Multilingual multi-sites, ideal for complex structures

Drupal:

• Headless architecture, mobile & omnichannel-capable

Regional use & community

TYPO3:

• Governments, universities & NGOs in the DACH region

Drupal:

• Widely used in USA, UK, India - strong international community

Source: typo3.org, drupal.org

TYPO3 websites

• German Red Cross (DRK): Crisis information and donation platform
• Lufthansa Group: Content management across several brands
• Volkswagen Foundation: Multilingual funding portal
• University Hospital Erlangen: Medical research & health services

• The Economist: Media & subscription portal
• NASA: Science & Technology Portal
• Oxford University: Student & research management
• Pfizer: Product & knowledge platform in the healthcare sector
• Shopify: User-friendly platform for start-ups pursuing innovative approaches in sustainable fashion

Source: trends.builtwith.com

TYPO3

Pros:

• Enterprise-ready: Ideal for large organizations
• Native multilingualism & multi-site: No additional effort
• Long-term support: LTS & ELTS
• DACH market: Particularly popular in Germany, Austria & Switzerland
• Clear backend for editors

Cons:

• High entry hurdle: TypoScript requires training
• Smaller range of extensions
• Less widespread globally
• Technical setup: specialist knowledge required
• Steeper learning curve: A disadvantage, but mitigated by the available documentation and community support

Drupal

Pros:

• Extremely flexible: Ideal for individual websites
• Huge collection of modules
• Large community worldwide
• Ideal for public authorities & educational institutions
• Secure & scalable

Cons:

• Developer-oriented: More difficult for beginners
• Complex updates: Regular maintenance necessary
• Multilingualism more complex
• Oversized for simple sites

And there you have it - a clear comparison between TYPO3 and Drupal! We hope this overview has helped you understand the pros and cons of both systems and helped you make the right choice for your project. The role of CMS (content management systems) plays a crucial role, especially when it comes to security and community.

If you choose TYPO3, we will be happy to help you with the implementation. As a leading TYPO3 agency we offer customized CMS solutions for your company.

Contact us NITSAN today - and let's realize your perfect website together!